X Factor 2011: Tulisa scraps "posh" boy band but saves "shining star" Charlie in judges houses shake-up


X Factor 2011: Tulisa scraps “posh” boy band but saves “shining star” Charlie in judges houses shake-up

12:13 AM on 2nd October 2011

Lifeline: Charlie Healy has been offered a second chance at the expense of the other members of Chasing Keys, pictured below performing at Tulisa

Lifeline: Charlie Healy has been offered a second chance at the expense of the other members of Chasing Keys, pictured below performing at Tulisa”s house in Mykanos

 Tulisa described Charlie

Tulisa described Charlie”s singing: “When Charlie is singing a line to you, and he”s singing it to you, you believe it”

Dilemma: Both Tulisa and Jessie J agreed that Charlie stood out from his bandmates, but weren

Dilemma: Both Tulisa and Jessie J agreed that Charlie stood out from his bandmates, but weren”t comfortable putting the group though as a whole

Emotional: Charlie described before their performance how difficult it felt to be rejected from something you love

Emotional: Charlie described before their performance how difficult it felt to be rejected from something you love

Stole the show: The others

Stole the show: The others” shaky vocals made Charlie”s voice stand out even more for the judges

Bitter: Charlie Healy is now said to be joining The Risk, reportedly prompting speculation from the others that they were deemed

Bitter: Charlie Healy is now said to be joining The Risk, reportedly prompting speculation from the others that they were deemed “too posh” for the show

Making it work: Tulisa said that she felt there was

Making it work: Tulisa said that she felt there was “something missing” from another group, and that adding Charlie to their number would be the perfect way of fixing this

Awaiting the verdict: Tulisa

Awaiting the verdict: Tulisa”s news came as an unpleasant shock to the other band members

Something missing: The Risk see a shake up as members Marlon McKenzie and Mitchell McPike have reportedly been axed to make room for Charlie

Something missing: The Risk see a shake up as members Marlon McKenzie and Mitchell McPike have reportedly been axed to make room for Charlie

First audition: Chasing Keys impressed initially with their tuneful rendition of

First audition: Chasing Keys impressed initially with their tuneful rendition of “I Need A Dollar”

Pivotal moment: The judges face Tulisa and a crutch-wielding Jessie J for the next pivotal stage of the competition

Pivotal moment: The judges face Tulisa and a crutch-wielding Jessie J for the next pivotal stage of the competition

Thrilled: The eight male hopefuls had no problem with Robbie

Thrilled: The eight male hopefuls had no problem with Robbie”s ensemble

Fragile: 16-year-old Luke Lucas broke down during his performance, prompting concern from Gary Fragile: 16-year-old Luke Lucas broke down during his performance, prompting concern from Gary

Fragile: 16-year-old Luke Lucas broke down during his performance, prompting concern from Gary

Uncomfortable: Gary told Luke to stop and start again

Uncomfortable: Gary told Luke to stop and start again

Tough decision: Robbie wanted to see Luke go through based on the strength of his first audition

Tough decision: Robbie wanted to see Luke go through based on the strength of his first audition

Remember when our hair looked like that Robbie and Gary loved Frankie

Remember when our hair looked like that Robbie and Gary loved Frankie”s performance, but also poked fun at his messy “do

Feeling the heat: John and Max were just two of the guys who sang to their mentor hoping to impress him Feeling the heat: John said auditioning for the second time at judges houses was harder because the pressure was greater, while Marcus belted out We Got Family by Paloma Faith

Feeling the heat: John said auditioning for the second time at judges houses was harder because the pressure was greater, while Marcus belted out We Got Family by Paloma Faith

Dream girls: Kelly Rowland was joined in her Miami home by Oscar winner and singer Jennifer Hudson

Dream girls: Kelly Rowland was joined in her Miami home by Oscar winner and singer Jennifer Hudson

Entranced: Jennifer Hudson loved 16-year-old Janet Devlin Entranced: Jennifer Hudson loved 16-year-old Janet Devlin

Entranced: Jennifer Hudson loved 16-year-old Janet Devlin”s rendition of Christina Aguilera”s Beautiful

Miami girls: Melanie and Misha wore contrasting colours to perform at Kelly Miami girls: Melanie and Misha wore contrasting colours to perform at Kelly

Miami girls: Melanie belted out Bruno Mars” Grenade, while Misha impressed Kelly and Tulisa

Was it enough: Jade sang a beautiful rendition of I Can

Was it enough Jade sang a beautiful rendition of I Can”t Make you Love Me but Kelly and Jennifer were concerned that her voice lacked “a certain something” tonight

Nervous: Holly (left) appeared to be really concentrating as she performed her audition in front of the two superstar singers whereas Amelia Lili seemed more confident Nervous: Holly (left) appeared to be really concentrating as she performed her audition in front of the two superstar singers whereas Amelia Lili seemed more confident

Nervous: Holly (left) put in a stellar performance while Amelia Lili dazzled with Katy Perry “Extraterrestrial”which Kelly said she sang like it was written for her

Audience favourite: Sammi sang New York by Alicia Keys, while Carolynn performed Need You Now by Lady Antebellum Audience favourite: Sammi sang New York by Alicia Keys, while Carolynn performed Need You Now by Lady Antebellum

Audience favourite: Sammi sang New York by Alicia Keys, while Carolynn performed Need You Now by Lady Antebellum

Surprise success: Johnny Robinson impressed Sinitta and Louis Walsh with Amy Winehouse

Surprise success: Johnny Robinson impressed Sinitta and Louis Walsh with Amy Winehouse”s Love Is A Losing Game

Never dull: Kitty Brucknell jumped into the pool after singing Kelly Clarkson

Never dull: Kitty Brucknell jumped into the pool after singing Kelly Clarkson”s Beautiful Disaster